21 Halloween Monster Eyes Recipes to Scare Up Some Fun

Get ready to add a playful twist to your Halloween festivities with these spooky monster eyes recipes that are sure to delight and entertain! Perfect for parties, gatherings, or simply to enjoy with family, these fun and creative treats will bring a festive flair to your celebration. With their whimsical designs and delicious flavors, these monster eyes are not only eye-catching but also a fantastic way to engage guests of all ages.

Halloween Monster Eye Crinkle Cookies

You might like to add these Halloween monster eye crinkle cookies to your Halloween plans this year! And no, it’s never too early to start planning what to make for Halloween. The great thing about making spooky Halloween treats is how fun they are. Making any kind of cookies and cakes is enjoyable, but making Halloween cookies is even more fun!
Get the Recipe: Halloween Monster Eye Crinkle Cookies

Halloween Eyeball Jello Shots

These fun Halloween party shots are quick, easy to make, and oh-so eye-catching! Halloween eyeball jello shots look cute and spooky, and everyone will want one, or even a matching pair! You only need four ingredients to prepare these spine-chilling jello shots – strawberry jello, red berry vodka, boiling water, and candy eyeballs or gummy eyeballs.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Eyeball Jello Shots

Halloween Eyeball Punch

Halloween is the one time of year you can go crazy making all kinds of spooktacular treats, and nothing is off-limits. In fact, the scarier the better, and this Halloween eyeball punch is one great way to kick off your Halloween party in style! A Halloween punch recipe is perfect for a crowd and, despite its disturbing appearance, it tastes really good!
Get the Recipe: Halloween Eyeball Punch

Spooky Halloween Monster Eye Pretzels

It can be hard knowing what to make for Halloween because there are just so many great recipes! I love these Halloween monster eye pretzels for more than one reason. They look great and taste fantastic. Plus, you only need 3 ingredients to make these spooky monster treats!
Get the Recipe: Spooky Halloween Monster Eye Pretzels

Spooky Halloween White Chocolate Candy Bark

Have you ever made Halloween white chocolate candy bark before? It’s one of my favourite Halloween snacks and every year I make it. I’ve enjoyed this Halloween bark recipe since I was little. And now I make my own! Halloween just wouldn’t be the same without this easy candy bark recipe.
Get the Recipe: Spooky Halloween White Chocolate Candy Bark

Frankenstein Apple Cider Halloween Donuts

I love these Frankenstein apple cider Halloween donuts. They’re impossibly cute and Halloween donut decorating is fun! Baked apple cider donuts boast plenty of fantastic fall flavour in every bite. Everyone will ADORE this spooky baked Halloween donut that looks like a Frankenstein monster.
Get the Recipe: Frankenstein Apple Cider Halloween Donuts

Halloween Antipasto Eyeballs Appetizer

Although there are literally hundreds, if not thousands, of Halloween appetizers to choose from, antipasto eyeballs are one of the most fun. Suitable for any Halloween party, this Halloween charcuterie board addition looks great and combines a variety of wonderful Italian flavours in every mouthful, including mozzarella, ham, fresh basil, sun-dried tomatoes, and more.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Antipasto Eyeballs Appetizer

Halloween Mummy Stromboli Dinner

Not only does this Halloween mummy stromboli make a great Halloween dinner or appetizer, but it also uses ingredients I’m sure you already have in the pantry and refrigerator (well, maybe not the candy eyeballs!) Pillsbury refrigerated pizza dough pairs with deli meat, cheese, peppers, seasonings, and marinara sauce to make this deliciously unusual homemade stromboli.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Mummy Stromboli Dinner

Mummy Halloween Hot Dogs

Considering this 4-ingredient Halloween dinner is so simple, you should definitely make mummy Halloween hot dogs this year. This scary hot dog snack is great for everyone, especially the kids, since they’re fun to look at and tasty to eat. If you love hot dogs, you are going to love spooky pigs in a blanket.
Get the Recipe: Mummy Halloween Hot Dogs

Halloween Snickers Mummy Treats

You can make easy Halloween Snickers mummy treats with just a few ingredients. Pillsbury crescent rolls, fun size Snickers, powdered sugar, and candy eyes come together for a great mummy dessert everyone will love, especially the kids or anyone with a sweet tooth! They make a nice dessert or a worthy addition to your Halloween buffet table.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Snickers Mummy Treats

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs

While they might look like bleeding eye balls, I promise you that these cookies have so much decadent peanut butter flavor in each bite.
Get the Recipe: Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs

Chocolate Eyeball Cookies

This cookie is the one to offer on Halloween night. They are dark, spooky and so much fun on the scariest night of the year.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Eyeball Cookies

Eyeball Jello Shots

Make these blood red jello shots with gummy eyeballs for the creepiest cocktail to share with your friends on Halloween night. These are easy, festive and so much fun!
Get the Recipe: Eyeball Jello Shots

Bloody Eye Apple Martini

Use lychees to make some tasty yet spooky eyeballs for your apple martini on Halloween night. This easy addition is perfect for any party!
Get the Recipe: Bloody Eye Apple Martini

Monster Eye Dip

This cream cheese dip goes great with cookies, fruit or even pretzels for a Halloween snack you will want to keep an eye on! It might vanish before you get a chance to try it!
Get the Recipe: Monster Eye Dip

Monster Yogurt Eyes

This yogurt snack uses fruit to make a delicious eyeball. You are going to love this healthy option for Halloween.
Get the Recipe: Monster Yogurt Eyes

Eye Cocoa Bombs

Warm up on Halloween night with a freakishly fun cocoa bomb! These look just like eyeballs, but have the best chocolate flavor!
Get the Recipe: Eye Cocoa Bombs

Glowing Eyeball Cupcakes

This recipe is so much fun! It includes a party favor that will help light up your Halloween night with colorful glow sticks and good snacks!
Get the Recipe: Glowing Eyeball Cupcakes

Googly Eye Cookies

Everyone will scream for one of these shaker cookies! While they take a little work to prepare, they are well worth the effort for a sweet to scream for!
Get the Recipe: Googly Eye Cookies

White Chocolate Eyeballs

If you make this homemade candy for Halloween, you can rest assured no one will be able to take their eyes from the dessert table. These are perfect for a decadent snack to share.
Get the Recipe: White Chocolate Eyeballs

Halloween Panna Cotta Eyeballs

There is no shortage of gross looking Halloween food making an appearance on October 31st every year. But these Halloween panna cotta eyeballs are extra gross! This gluten free Halloween dessert that looks like eyeballs is one of my favourite Halloween party food ideas for adults and kids.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Panna Cotta Eyeballs